Hiring a Roofer? Here’s the Complete Guide to Spotting Scams and Choosing a Pro

Choosing the right roofing contractor is one of the most important decisions you'll make for your roof replacement project. A great roofer means a high-quality roof installation and peace of mind, while a bad one can lead to costly repairs and years of headaches. To protect your investment, you need to check them thoroughly.

This guide provides the 10 essential roofing questions you must ask during your first meeting. Their answers will tell you everything you need to know about their professionalism, reliability, and the quality of their roofing work.

The 10 Essential Questions to Ask Any Roofing Contractor

Think of this list as your consumer protection playbook. When evaluating roofing contractors, a true professional roofer will welcome your questions and provide clear, confident answers. Any hesitation or vague responses should be considered a red flag.

1. Are You Licensed and Insured?

• What purpose it serve: This is the most critical question for your protection. Proper licensing ensures the contractor meets local standards, while insurance coverage (both general liability insurance and workers' compensation) protects you from being financially liable for accidents or property damage.

• Red flags to look out for: Any hesitation to provide proof, or a roofer who claims you don't need it or that your homeowners' insurance is enough to cover their work.

2. What is Your Company's Full Name and Physical Address?

• What purpose it serves: This verifies that they are a legitimate, established roofing business with a physical location you can find. It helps you avoid "storm chasers" who operate out of a truck and may disappear after the job is done.

• Red flags to look out for: A contractor who only provides a post office box, has no online presence, or is vague about their company's details.

3. Can You Provide Local References?

• What purpose it serves: This allows you to verify their proven track record by speaking directly with recent past customers in your area. It’s the best way to get honest feedback on their work quality, professionalism, and reliability.

• Red flags to look out for: Inability or unwillingness to provide references, or providing references who are unreachable or vague.

4. Who Will Be Performing the Work? Your Employees or Subcontractors?

• What purpose it serves: You need to know exactly who will be on your property. If they use roofing subcontractors, you have the right to know if that crew is also fully insured and experienced.

• Red flags to look out for: A contractor who is unclear about who will perform the roofing work or cannot verify the insurance of their subcontractors.

5. Will You Provide a Detailed, Itemized Written Estimate?

• What purpose it serves: A detailed written estimate prevents surprise charges. It breaks down all material costs, labor costs, and other costs (like permits and disposal), allowing you to compare roofing quotes accurately.

• Red flags to look out for: A vague, lump sum price on a handshake or a simple invoice. A professional will always itemize the cost.

6. What Warranties Do You Offer on Your Workmanship?

• What purpose it serves: This clarifies the contractor's personal guarantee on the quality of their roof installation, which is separate from the manufacturer's warranty on the roofing materials. A strong workmanship warranty shows they stand by their work.

• Red flags to look out for: A roofer who is vague about their warranty or only mentions the material warranty. Insist on getting their workmanship guarantee in writing.

7. How Will You Protect My Property During the Project?

• What purpose does it serve? This question gauges their professionalism and respect for your home. A good roofer will have a clear plan to protect your landscaping, siding, windows, and driveway from falling debris.

• Red flags to look out for: A contractor who dismisses the question or doesn't have a specific plan. This can be a sign of a messy, careless roofing job.

8. What is the Process for Unexpected Issues, Like Rotted Decking?

• What purpose it serves: This sets clear expectations for how unforeseen costs are handled. A professional will have a standard procedure and will specify the cost of potential roof deck repairs in the contract.

• Red flags to look out for: A contractor who says, "We'll figure it out if it happens." This can lead to inflated, high-pressure charges mid-project.

9. What is Your Payment Schedule?

• What purpose it serves: This protects you from scams. Reputable contractors have fair payment terms and never ask for the full amount up front.

• Red flags to look out for: A roofer who demands a large cash deposit (over 30%) or asks for the full payment before the roofing work is complete.

10. What is the Estimated Timeline for the Project?

• What purpose it serves: This helps you manage your expectations and plan your life around the home improvement project. It also clarifies how the contractor will communicate about potential delays.

• Red flags to look out for: An overly optimistic timeline that doesn't account for potential inclement weather, or an unwillingness to commit to a start and end date.

Red Flags to Look Out For While Hiring

As you're evaluating roofing contractors, some signs are more serious than others. Though mentioned briefly in the questions above, these are the major red flags that tell you to hang up the phone and find someone else:

Think of this as your "red flag cheat sheet."

1. No Proof of Insurance or Licensing

If a roofer can't immediately provide a copy of their general liability insurance and workers' compensation, end the conversation. This is the biggest red flag, as it means you would be financially responsible for any accidents or property damage.

2. Demands a Large Cash Deposit or Full Payment Upfront

A reputable roofing contractor will ask for a reasonable deposit (10-30%) to cover materials. A contractor who demands a huge cash deposit or the full payment before the roofing job is complete is a major flight risk, and this is a common scam tactic.

3. Provides a Vague, Non-Itemized Estimate

A quote on a handshake or a single price on a business card is the sign of an amateur. A professional roofer will always provide a detailed, written estimate that breaks down the costs for materials, labor, and permits, so you know exactly what you're paying for.

4. Has No Local, Physical Address

Be very wary of any contractor who only has a post office box or an out of state number. You want to hire a roofing company with a permanent physical location in your community that will be around to honor their workmanship warranty.

5. Uses High-Pressure Sales Tactics

A roofer who pressures you to sign a contract on the spot, claims the "special price" is only for today, or tries to scare you into a quick decision is a major red flag. A professional will give you time to review roofing quotes and make a considered hiring decision.

6. Cannot Provide Local References

A reputable roofer with a proven track record will be proud to share their work. If a contractor is hesitant or unable to provide references from recent past customers, it's often a sign that they don't have a history of satisfied clients.

Conclusion: Ask Questions, Get Confidence

Asking these roofing questions isn't about being difficult...It's about being a smart consumer when making a hiring decision.

Choosing the right roofer for your roof replacement is a big investment. A true professional roofer will welcome your questions and provide clear answers.

Taking the time to thoroughly vet your contractor is the single best way to ensure a smooth, successful project and protect your home for decades to come.

Ready to talk to a contractor? First, get a clear idea of your budget.

>> Calculate Your Personalized Roof Replacement Cost for Free <<