Key Takeaways

In a hurry? Here is the bottom line on the cost vs. value debate:

• The Upfront Winner. Asphalt shingles are much cheaper today. You can expect to pay $4.25 to $8.50 per square foot, while metal roofing often starts around $9.00 to $14.00+ per square foot.

• The Lifespan Winner. A metal roof can last 40 to 70 years, while an asphalt shingle roof typically lasts 15 to 30 years.

• The ROI Reality. If you plan to stay in your home for decades, metal often pays off by avoiding a second roof replacement.

• Energy Savings. Metal reflects heat, potentially lowering cooling bills by 20% to 40%, which adds up to thousands in savings over the life of the roof.

• Resale Value. Both add value, but metal roofs can recoup a higher percentage of their cost (up to 85%) at resale compared to asphalt (60-70%).

Want to see the specific price difference for your home?

>> Get an Instant, Personalized Estimate with Our Free Roof Replacement Cost Calculator <<

Asphalt Roof Replacement Cost vs. Metal Roof: Which Pays Off Long Term?

Choosing between asphalt shingles and metal roofing is the biggest financial decision you will make for your roofing project.

Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in the roofing industry because they are affordable and effective. Metal roofs, however, are rapidly gaining popularity as a premium option that offers incredible durability.

To make the right choice, you need to look past the initial estimate and understand the true cost of ownership. This guide breaks down the actual cost, lifespan, and return on investment for both materials so you can see which one really pays off.

The Upfront Cost: What You Pay Today

Let's start with the number that hits your wallet first. There is a significant gap between the asphalt roof replacement cost and the price of a metal one.

Asphalt Shingle Roof Cost

For most homeowners, this is the budget-friendly benchmark.

• Average Cost: A typical asphalt shingle roof for a standard 2,000 square foot home costs between $8,500 and $17,000.

• Breakdown:
• 
  
• 3-Tab Shingles: The most basic option. Very cheap but shortest lifespan.

• Architectural Asphalt Shingles: The standard for a new roof today. They cost a bit more ($6 - $10 per square foot) but look better and last longer.

• Why it's cheaper: The material costs are lower, and labor costs are less because roofing contractors can install them quickly.

Metal Roof Cost

This is a premium upgrade. Expect a significantly higher upfront investment, but know that you are paying for superior durability and a roof that can last a lifetime.

• Average Cost: A metal roof for the same home typically costs between $18,000 and $40,000+.

• Breakdown:

• Steel (Metal Shingles or Panels): The most affordable metal option ($9 - $16 per square foot).

• Aluminum & Premium Metals: Higher costs for materials like aluminum or copper roofing, which can go much higher.

• Why it's more expensive: The materials cost more to manufacture, and the roof installation requires specialized labor and more time.

The Long Game: Lifespan and Replacement Cycles

This is where the math starts to change. You aren't just buying a roof; you are buying years of protection.

• The Asphalt Cycle. An asphalt shingle roof generally lasts 15 to 30 years. If you buy your "forever home" at age 30, you will likely pay for two or even three roof replacements in your lifetime. That means paying for materials, labor, and inflation multiple times.

• The Metal Cycle. A metal roof lasts 40 to 70 years or more. It is often a "one and done" investment. You pay more today, but you essentially pre-pay for decades of worry free living. You avoid the future cost to replace your roof entirely.

• The Verdict: If you plan to move in 5 to 10 years, asphalt shingles make more financial sense. If you plan to stay for 20+ years, metal becomes a very strong financial contender.

To see how these lifespans compare against other materials like slate or wood, read our deep dive: How Long Does a Roof Last? Lifespan by Material and Climate.

Hidden Savings: Energy Efficiency and Maintenance

The sticker price doesn't tell the whole story. Metal roofing puts money back in your pocket in ways asphalt cannot.

Energy Bills

• Asphalt: Traditional dark shingles absorb heat, radiating it into your attic and making your AC work harder.

• Metal: Metal reflects solar heat. Studies show a metal roof can reduce cooling energy use by 20% to 40%. Over 30 years, that monthly saving adds up to thousands of dollars, effectively lowering the overall cost of the roof.

Maintenance and Repairs

• Asphalt: Vulnerable to wind, hail, and moss. You will likely spend money on minor roof repairs or replacing missing shingles over the years.

• Metal: Extremely durable. It stands up to severe weather and requires almost no maintenance. You save money by avoiding the cost of constant upkeep.

ROI and Resale Value: Getting Your Money Back

What happens when you sell? Both roofs add value, but in different ways.

• Asphalt ROI: A new asphalt shingle roof is a great selling point. It tells buyers the home is well-maintained. You can typically recoup about 60% to 70% of the project costs in home value.

• Metal ROI: A metal roof is a premium feature that boosts curb appeal and signals high quality. Because it lasts so long, buyers are often willing to pay more. You can often recoup 60% to 85% of the cost at resale, and homes with metal roofs may sell faster.

Which One is Right for You? A Quick Comparison

Smart Homeowner Considerations

Before you sign a contract, consider these final factors.

• Your Budget: If the price tag for metal feels too steep, don't worry. Architectural shingles are the most popular roofing material for a reason—they offer a fantastic balance of durability, aesthetics, and affordability.

• HOA Rules: Some neighborhoods restrict roof types. Check if metal roofing is even allowed in your area before you fall in love with it.

• Roof Pitch and Complexity: Metal roofs can be tricky to install on complex roofs with many angles or skylights, which can drive labor costs even higher. Asphalt is very flexible and easier to install on any roof design.

• Insurance: Check with your insurance company. You might get a discount on your premiums for installing an impact-resistant metal roof or Class 4 asphalt shingle, which helps offset the cost.

Conclusion: Choosing the Best Value for Your Situation

So, which one pays off? If you are looking at the strictly lowest upfront price, asphalt shingles win every time. They are the cost-effective solution for most homeowners. However, if you look at the total cost of ownership over 40 or 50 years, a metal roof often wins.

It saves you from paying for a second roof replacement, lowers your energy bills, and raises your home's value. The "best" choice depends entirely on your timeline and your budget.

Still on the fence about which material fits your home best? You can explore all your options in The Complete Guide to Roofing Materials: Pros, Cons, and Costs.

You have the knowledge, now get your personalized numbers. A real budget starts with a real estimate.

>> Calculate Your Personalized Roof Replacement Cost for Free <<